• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Home
  • About
    • Awards & Honors, Pomp & Circumstance
  • Blog
    • Modern, 18th, 19th Century
    • Baroque, Rococo
    • Renaissance
    • Ancient, Roman, Medieval
    • Culture, Festivals, Music, Literature
    • Art News, Current Events
  • FaceBook
  • Pinterest
  • Italian with Melissa
    • Studentessa Matta Italian Site
    • Learn Italian at home with Melissa
    • Study in Italy with Melissa
  • Melissa’s Books
    • Melissa’s Author Website
  • Store
  • Sign Up & Connect
  • Nav Social Menu

    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
Art of Loving Italy

Art of Loving Italy

Art & Beauty are all around us.

Tale of Two Crosses by Cimabue

May 2, 2017 by Melissa Muldoon Leave a Comment

Cimabue-cross-arezzo-florence
Cimabue: Detail of Christ on Cross

Cimabue was a Florentine painter who lived from 1251 until 1302. He is significant in that he is one of the first painters to shift from stylistic representations popular during the medieval ages, signifying a turning point in Art History toward the Renaissance.

Paintings before Cimabue were flat with little or no depth and figures had a highly stylized look. What do we attribute this to? During the middle ages, artists had limited understanding of correct body proportions or an understanding of how to communicate three-dimensionality. But, also artists were not all that interested in creating actual depth and replicating the human experience. Rather they were interested in creating a divine realm that reflected an otherworldly quality through the shimmering gold reflections and highly stylized figures floating in unreal spaces. They were also greatly influenced by Byzantine art. As a result, they created paintings on wooden panels using egg tempera, the backgrounds of which consisted mainly of flat surfaces burnished with thin sheets of real gold.

Cimabue-cross-arezzo-florence
Cimabue: Detail of Christ on Cross

But, at the time Cimabue began painting, artists were on the cusp of a new age. This is marked by a new interest in painting in a more naturalistic way. Cimabue started to pay closer attention to the real world making the individuals in his paintings less elongated and less stylized. We begin to see more monumental well-developed forms that are described by light and shadow. Also, the placement of figures begins to make more sense to us. They seem to exist more realistically in a three-dimensional world that fits our own experience instead of a made-up ethereal realm that defies human logic.

Why did this shift in ways of seeing and painting occur at this time in Florence? There are several theories, one being that artists were starting to move away from Byzantine styles due to their Islamic forces that were growing stronger in the Eastern Empires. They returned to Italy and were prompted to think more innovatively. Also, there was a renewed interest in studying languages and cultures of ancient Greece and Rome, thus giving rise to a more humanistic approach in art; there was more concentration on human activities and possibilities, instead of focusing only on the extreme importance of God.

Cimabue-cross-arezzo-florence
Cimabue: Crucifix

Cimabue was one of the first to give a hint of this new artistic vision. We can see him making this transition in two crosses he painted. One Cross was done in 1240 for the Church of San Domenico in Arezzo (painting on the left). The other was painted for the Franciscan order in 1268 to hang in Santa Croce in Florence (painting on the right)

Both paintings feature Christ as the central image of the Virgin and John the Evangelist who flank him in small rectangular panels on either side of his outstretched arms. Comparing the two, the first thing to note is that there are still traces of the Byzantine style evident in the use of hammered gold backgrounds. But in both versions, we see a shift away from a triumphant Christ on the Cross, to a more graphic portrayal of human suffering. He is less mystical and seems to share the burden and pain of humanity. This stylistic and philosophical shift in the art will later be picked up by his student Giotto and will go on to influence artists like Michelangelo, Caravaggio, and Velázquez.

Further comparisons make us realize the maturing of Cimabue’s style away from flat representations to a more humanistic one. In the Florentine version, for example, the figure is more refined; its proportions are less strict; the S curve of Christ is more pronounced. Note also how his foot extends the frame. Also, the coloring and shadowing seem more defined and sophisticated. In the Florentine version, Christ’s face is longer and his nose less idealized.

Cimabue-cross-arezzo-florence
Photo Credit: Firenze Today Archivio Foto Locchi

Today you can still see both these crosses. The one in Arezzo is well preserved. The one in Florence has suffered from several floods over the past few years – one in 1333, one in 1557, and the most recent in 1966. During that flood, which is described in the book Dreaming Sophia, the waterline in Santa Croce church reached the height of Christ’s halo. The wooden frame swelled causing the paint to expand and bend and crack off. The Crucifix lost 60% of its paint.

Cimabue-cross-arezzo-florence
Cimabue Crucifix before and after the flood

Thanks to the work of Umberto Baldini a team of restorers spent ten years reapplying paint that they found floating around the piece after the floodwaters resided. It was also necessary to separate the original gesso and canvas from its wooden backing to prevent further buckling as the reapplied paint dried. In 1976 the painting was close to its initial appearance and was put back on public display.

Cimabue-cross-arezzo-florence
Cimabue damaged Crucifix

Looking closely at both Crucifixes painted by Cimabue, we realize they indeed are communicating volumes. They tell a story about an artist who was beginning to see the world in a new way, indicating a pivotal turning point in Art History. But it is also fascinating to learn about the trials and tribulations Cimabue’s Crosses have undergone over the years just to survive to tell their tale.

If you liked this article you might like these too:

Giorgio Vasari First Art Historian

Leonardo’s Advice to Sophia – Sketch Everything you see!

Tribute to the Mud Angels 50th Anniversary Florence’s Flood

Share this post

Share
Tweet
Pin
Share
Share
Email

Related Posts

Filed Under: Medieval, Renaissance Tagged With: Arezzo, Cimabue Crocifisso, Cimabue Cross, Florence Flood, San Domenico, Santa Croce

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment. I love hearing from you in English or Italian! Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to the Art of Loving Italy Blog

Follow along on Instagram @studentessamatta

Matta per l’Italia! That’s me! La Studentessa Matta per l’Italia! That’s me! La Studentessa Matta! I’m Crazy for Italy!

Are you crazy in love with Italy and the language too? Are you learning Italian but have no one to practice with? Do you need a language coach or want to practice Italian conversation skills? Want to join an Italian Book club and read a novel in Italian?

Or perhaps you want to learn Italian in Italy and immerse in the language and culture?

Join me on my website for lots of Italian language learning fun! I’ve got lots of ways for you to practice and improve.

Many times, I’ve heard, “I can read and understand Italian, but when I speak, I get tongue-tied!” Sound familiar? Now you can practice Italian Conversation with me, loosen your tongue, and polish your language skills regularly. Do you need help with Italian grammar? Now you can schedule Italian Lessons to improve your language abilities. We will kick the tires and check the gearbox to get your “Italian Language Vespa’s” motor running smoothly and efficiently.

Or join me in Italy to learn the language on one of my specially designed programs with one of my partner schools. Learn in the classroom in the morning, and join me on excursions and adventures in the afternoon to keep practicing and learning more Italian!

In 2023 I have three small group programs planned with my partner schools in Arezzo in June, Lucca at the end of August, and Montepulciano in September! 

Join me, and let’s love Italy and Italian together! Improve your fluency and understanding of this beautiful language with me — la Matta!

For information about online language lessons with Melissa, the Studentessa Matta or to learn more and to sign up for one of the Matta 2023 Italian Language Immersion programs visit the www.StudentessaMatta.com website. Links in bio.

#ItalianLanguageProgram #ItalyStudyAbroad #SpeakItalian #StudentessaMatta #italianLanguage #TravelItaly #ItalianCulture #italian #ItalianVerbs #ItalianLessons #ARezzo #Montepulciano #LuccaItalianSchool #GiostraSaracino #LuccaWall #MontepulcianoWine #studyitalian
Love Italy!?!? Love the language? Do I have an ide Love Italy!?!? Love the language? Do I have an idea for you! 

How about packing your bags and heading to Montepulciano, Italy to learn Italian with Melissa the Studentessa Matta? Che bello! 

2023 Matta and Il Sasso Montepulciano Language Program: September, 10 - 22

Not only will you improve your language skills, but you’ll also get to indulge in the scrumptious Italian cuisine and wine, and explore the beautiful surroundings of Tuscany. 

It’s the perfect blend of learning and adventure, and who knows, you might even make some new Italian friends along the way. 

Montepulciano is a beautiful town located in the Tuscany region of Italy. It is known for its picturesque landscapes, historic architecture, and delicious food and wine. The town has a rich cultural heritage and is home to numerous cultural events and festivals throughout the year.

Melissa the Studentessa Matta is an experienced Italian language teacher who has a passion for teaching the language and sharing her knowledge and love of Italy with others. Her language courses are designed to be immersive and engaging, and she uses a variety of teaching methods to help her students learn and practice Italian in a fun and effective way.

Learning Italian with Melissa in Montepulciano would allow you to not only improve your language skills but also experience Italian culture firsthand. You would have the opportunity to interact with locals, try authentic Italian cuisine, and visit historic landmarks and museums. By learning Italian in Montepulciano with Melissa, you would be able to take advantage of the beautiful surroundings and cultural events to enhance your learning experience.

So, what are you waiting for? Let’s go Italiano! Andiamo!

For more information and to sign up for the September Matta Montepulciano program find links in bio.

#LearnItalian #ItalianLanguage #ItalianCulture #ItalianExperience #StudentessaMatta #Montepulciano #Tuscany #ItalyTravel #TravelToItaly #LanguageLearning #CulturalImmersion #LaDolceVita #LanguageTravel #ExploreItaly #ItalianAdventure #LanguageClasses #SpeakItalian #ItalyStudyAbroad
The best way to keep up with your Italian is by li The best way to keep up with your Italian is by listening to audiobooks in Italian. There are lots of good books on Amazon Audible! 

Here are my latest listening stats: In the last four months, you pressed play on 23 titles, listened for 9,138 mins, averaged 76 min/day, and devoured 327 min on Feb 12. 

Il modo migliore per stare a passo con il tuo italiano e ascoltare gli audiobook. Ci sono tanti libri su amazon Audible! 

Buon ascolto! Buona lettura.

Happy listening! Happy reading!

Find Italian novels and audiobooks on the Matta Amazon Italian Page - Books, gifts & more!

Link in bio to my Amazon store page

#audiobooksItalian #Audible #AmazonAudible #AmazonItalia #StudentessaMatta #learnItalian #ReadBooks #listenbookshelfgetoutofmyway
The Italian Subjunctive — il Congiuntivo — how The Italian Subjunctive — il Congiuntivo — how to conquer this great big beautiful ugly beast!

New post on the Studentessa Matta Website!

Ah, the dreaded congiuntivo - the Italian subjunctive mood! It terrorizes many people and gives them the chills as if it were a terrifying ogre that eats innocent students for breakfast. 

Are you too afraid of this intimidating beast!? 

The Italian Subjunctive mood is not all that scary, and it's time to demystify and make friends with it! 

In a new post on the Studentessa Matta blog you will understand the congiuntivo better, what it is, what triggers it, how to conjugate it, and how to use it with many practical examples. Puoi farcela! You can do it! You can conquer and tame the subjunctive and use it like a real Italian!

#Congiuntivo #ItalianGrammar #italianLanguage #ItalianVerbs#SubjunctiveMood #GrammarNerd #ItalianCulture #ItalianSyntax #SpeakItalian #StudentessaMatta #LearnItalialn #italian grammar #italianverbs #ItalianLesson #SpeakItalialn #italiancongiuntivo
New film review of Rapiniamo il Duce (Robbing Muss New film review of Rapiniamo il Duce (Robbing Mussolini) on the Studentessa Matta blog site.

Rapiniamo il Duce (Robbing Mussolini) is a new Netflix fiction action film partially based on actual events. 

It was well-known that Mussolini had a secret stash of treasures hidden away and heavily guarded. It contained all the gold, jewels, money, paintings, and precious objects he had stolen from the Italian people in the name of Fascism. In the final days of the war, to save himself, Mussolini fled north. 

We all know what fate befell the Duce and where he ended up, but what happened to his treasure and where it is now is still a mystery. In this new movie, a band of misfit thieves set out to steal the stash in the confusion of the last days of the war. 

Read my review, listen to music from the film, and feast your eyes on some of the fantastic costumes. 

#RobbingMussolini #RapiniamoIlDuce #ItalianCinema #NetflixOriginal #HeistMovie #PoliticalSatire #ComedyFilmItalian #HistoricalFiction #Fascism #ItalianResistance #Antifascist #ItalianCulturalHeritage #ArtTheft #ItalianHistory #Mussolini #Duce #DuceLostTreasure #OutrageousPlot #PracticeItalian #FilmItalian #StudentessaMatta
On today's date, in 2019, "Eternally Artemisia” On today's date, in 2019, "Eternally Artemisia” was published! Publication day is always a special date to remember and celebrate as it represents a huge milestone in the life of an author! I loved writing this story and I miss the days of living in Artemisia's world! 

The novel celebrates Artemisia Gentisleschi, the 17th-Century painter; her art and spirit are shown through various lifetimes. 

The story also explores the idea that when there is a profound attachment between two souls, who experience life so intensely and passionately, they are cosmically bound together. They endure through all seasons, never fading away, and are fated to meet repeatedly.

Find your copy of "Eternally Artemisia" on Amazon in print, epub for Kindle, and as an Audiobook. Links in Bio.

#Artemisia Gentileschi #EternallyArtemisia #Florence #Rome #Baroque #TimeTravel #SearchingUniverse #StrongWomen #EternalLove #NovelItaly #RenaissanceItaly #IsabellaMedici #Medici #Florence #Firenze #Arezzo #Rome #MussoliniHistory #SophiaLoren #SofonisbaAnguissola #Michelangelo #artHistory #ItalyNovel #ItalyArt #italytravel
Literal translations are like a slippery banana pe Literal translations are like a slippery banana peel on a language learner’s path to fluency! 

Think of it like this: translating word for word from your native language is like trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. It just doesn’t work! 

You need to learn the unique shape and style of the language you’re learning, just like you need to find the right shape and size of the puzzle piece to complete the picture.

I’ve compiled a list of expressions using FARE, PRENDERE, and AVERE to guide you. Look it over, familiarize yourself with the particular usages, and check out some idiomatic expressions using these verbs. 

Start reading and listening more in Italian; soon, your ear will recognize these expressions, which will start sounding more natural. 

And hey, if you slip on a grammatical “banana peel,” remember language learning is a journey, so just pick yourself up and keep going!

#ItalianGrammar #ItalianExpressions #StudentessaMatta #ItalianConversation #Fare #Prendere #Avere #ItalianVerbs #ExpressYourselfinItalian #ItalianLearningTips #ItalianCommunication #FaSenso #AvereFame #PrendersiInGiro #PrendereSole #Fareunafoto

Melissa Muldoon © 2023 Built with and Genesis Framework by Bellano Web Studio